Motor finance scheme hearing confirmed for February 2027: what lenders must do now

The Upper Tribunal will hear challenges to the FCA's motor finance compensation scheme on 16 to 26 February 2027. The scheme is partially suspended, but lenders have live obligations in the meantime.

Motor finance scheme hearing confirmed for February 2027: what lenders must do now
Illustration: AI-generated

Action required. Motor finance lenders only.

The Upper Tribunal has confirmed it will hear legal challenges to the FCA's motor finance compensation scheme (PS26/3) between 16 and 26 February 2027. Challenges were brought by three lenders (Volkswagen Financial Services, Mercedes-Benz Financial Services, and Crédit Agricole Auto Finance) and by the consumer group Consumer Voice, represented by Courmacs Legal.

The scheme was published on 30 March 2026. The Tribunal partially suspended it on 2 July 2026 on terms agreed between the FCA and the four challengers. Until the legal process concludes, lenders do not need to calculate or pay compensation.

That suspension does not mean lenders can stand down. Four obligations remain live. Lenders must identify relevant complaints and agreements. They must gather data on commission arrangements and disclosure practices from third-party brokers, and ensure those brokers supply requested documents within one month. They must also send letters to consumers not owed compensation under the scheme.

The FCA is explicit about the downside scenario: if the scheme is quashed entirely, each complaint reverts to the standard eight-week statutory resolution window. With potentially millions of agreements in scope, the administrative burden on lenders could be severe. The FCA expects lenders to be operationally and financially ready for that outcome, make the necessary financial provisions, and engage with their auditors now.

The scale of potential liability is significant. The FCA estimated total compensation under the scheme at approximately £7.5bn across around 12.1 million agreements, an average of about £830 each. Major lenders have already begun provisioning: the automotive industry total exceeds £1.5bn.

The FCA is also liaising with the Financial Ombudsman Service to ensure it is ready for an increase in cases if the scheme falls away and consumers are dissatisfied with individual complaint outcomes.

On the substance of the challenges: the lenders argue the scheme requires them to assume an unfair relationship existed where none did, and that redress is required without a proper connection to actual consumer loss. Consumer Voice argues the scheme does not go far enough for consumers.

No judgment timetable has been confirmed beyond the February 2027 hearing window.

Sources