FCA steps in as debt collector pursues disguised remuneration loan repayments
The FCA has secured voluntary restrictions on Ethica Resolve Limited, which was chasing repayment of loans made through disguised remuneration schemes on behalf of West 28th Street Limited, an unregulated buyer.
Worth reviewing if you are involved in debt purchase, collections, or consumer credit where the validity of underlying loans is in dispute.
Ethica Resolve Limited, an FCA-authorised debt servicer and collector, has agreed to voluntary restrictions after the FCA intervened over demands it made for repayment of loans made through disguised remuneration schemes. Ethica was acting on behalf of West 28th Street Limited, which bought the loan book from a third party and is itself not authorised or regulated by the FCA.
Disguised remuneration schemes paid contractors, consultants and agency workers through loans rather than salaries as a means of avoiding tax. Some of those now being chased dispute both their liability for the amounts claimed and whether the debts are legally enforceable at all.
Under the agreed restrictions, Ethica must write to affected consumers confirming they have no enforceable obligation to pay at this stage, must not make further payment demands under the current proposed court claim, and must not seek default judgments, that is, court orders against people who have not responded to a legal claim, while regulatory and legal issues remain unresolved. Additional protections for vulnerable consumers are also being put in place.
Enforceability is the central unresolved issue. Those seeking payment may need to obtain a Validation Order from the FCA under Section 28A of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, and potentially a court order under Section 127 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974, before the loans can be enforced. The FCA has said its agreement to any Validation Order application is not guaranteed, and if one is required but refused the debt remains unenforceable.
Whether those requirements apply to every loan being pursued is a separate unresolved question. Many arrangements originated as private loans between employers and employees, or trustees and beneficiaries, rather than conventional consumer loans. The legal position may therefore differ considerably between individual agreements.
The FCA's Consumer Credit sourcebook (CONC) requires firms to suspend recovery attempts where a customer disputes a debt on valid or potentially valid grounds while the dispute is investigated. Consumer Duty obligations apply where relevant.
The Ethica intervention follows an FCA statement published on 2 November 2026 warning that consumers were receiving legal letters threatening court action and demanding immediate repayment after disguised remuneration loans were sold by the original provider to a third party.
Consumers who receive formal court documents on this matter should not ignore them and should seek independent legal or debt advice before deciding how to respond.