FCA sets out settlement offer expectations for motor finance lenders as Barclays moves first
The FCA has published formal expectations for lenders wishing to make early compensation offers to car finance customers, even as legal challenges to its redress scheme remain live. Barclays Partner Finance is the first major lender to confirm it will act.
Worth reviewing: Motor finance lenders, and any firm tracking the car finance redress story.
The FCA published its expectations for lenders making settlement offers to car finance customers on 3 November 2026. The formal redress scheme remains partially suspended while legal challenges are heard by the Upper Tribunal between 16 February and 3 March 2027. In the meantime, firms must keep preparing for the scheme and progressing complaints, but do not need to calculate or pay compensation until the legal process concludes.
The FCA supports early settlement provided certain conditions are met. Any offer must be at least as generous as what the customer would receive under the formal scheme. Lenders must share a mandatory FCA factsheet with customers at the time of any offer, and are expected to notify the FCA before making offers. The FCA will publish and regularly update a list of participating lenders on its website so customers can verify whether an offer is genuine.
Customers who accept an offer keep the money regardless of how the legal challenge resolves, but they cannot return later for additional compensation if the outcome would have entitled them to more. Offers made outside the scheme cannot be referred to the Financial Ombudsman Service, but customers can simply reject an offer and wait for the formal scheme to run its course.
Not all lenders are expected to participate, and those that do may limit offers to a subset of eligible customers. Barclays Partner Finance has confirmed it will make offers to some customers, with early payments focused predominantly on Johnson cases: complaints involving an undisclosed contractual tie, a discretionary commission arrangement, or both, where commission was at least 50% of the total cost of credit and 22.5% of the loan.
The FCA estimates around 12.1m agreements could qualify under the scheme, with average compensation of approximately £829 per eligible agreement. A survey of 1,000 motor finance customers commissioned by the FCA found that 89% of those who had complained or were considering doing so wanted the choice of an offer now rather than waiting, and 77% said receiving compensation sooner would make a great deal or fair amount of difference to their financial situation. Lenders should note the FCA has reminded customers they can complain directly for free, without using a claims management company, which may charge up to 36% of compensation including VAT: a point that may affect how firms communicate with customers.