FCA follow-up survey finds CFD firms slow to act on overnight financing charges
The FCA's follow-up good and poor practice findings show most CFD firms have made only cosmetic changes six months on from its November 2025 review, and the regulator is signalling individual follow-up where concerns persist.
Action required if you manufacture, promote or distribute contracts for difference, spread bets or rolling-spot-forex to retail clients.
The FCA's contracts for difference good and poor practice publication covers all FCA-authorised investment firms in the CFD space and follows a May 2026 survey of 81 firms conducted six months after its November 2025 multi-firm review. The headline finding is blunt: most firms have done very little, and the FCA says it is disappointed.
Only 12% of firms said they had changed any charges. The majority limited their response to providing more information about existing rates rather than adjusting the rates themselves. The FCA notes that changes were often designed to demonstrate compliance rather than materially change the offering. Some firms remained clear outliers on overnight funding fees while making no material changes. The FCA says it is disappointed that nearly three years after the introduction of Consumer Duty, and six months after its own feedback, firms have not moved faster.
The charge levels themselves are one concern. The FCA has flagged that the level of overnight financing charges and how firms apply them may breach their price and value obligations under Consumer Duty. Some firms' charges appear high relative to prevailing base rates and peer comparisons, with wide spreads applied on both long and short positions.
Disclosure is the other. The FCA is concerned that firms are not giving clients enough information about overnight charges to meet their consumer understanding obligations. Only a minority of firms have added annual percentage rates alongside the implied daily percentage cost of overnight financing, which would give clients a more meaningful comparison point. Mark-ups within overnight funding charges remain largely opaque across the sector.
There is also a specific concern about matched or hedged positions, where a client holds simultaneous offsetting buy and sell CFDs on the same underlying asset. Most firms are applying the same full funding charge spread to these positions as to genuine directional exposures, often justifying this as an administration charge.
The FCA is not satisfied with that framing. Firms that permit or encourage clients to hold such positions should review all information provided throughout the client journey. The concern is that firms may be encouraging clients to maintain open positions that incur additional spread and funding charges.
The FCA points to dedicated web pages and pop-ups or overlays that clearly explain fees, including how they are calculated and the amounts, as good practice. These should be signposted prominently, not buried in terms and conditions or Key Information Documents. Firms that have moved to peer comparisons with UK-regulated providers, rather than offshore or global ones, are cited as good practice.
The FCA expects firms to be able to demonstrate they have reviewed their charges. No deadline is given, but the FCA's language and its stated intention to follow up individually mean firms should treat this as urgent rather than discretionary.
Sources
- Contracts difference firmsfca.org.uk