FCA consumer finance fair value review: good practice, clear gaps, and what you need to check

The FCA has set out where consumer finance firms are falling short on fair value under the Consumer Duty. If you lend to consumers, check your assessment against the findings now.

FCA consumer finance fair value review: good practice, clear gaps, and what you need to check
Illustration: AI-generated

Worth reviewing. Consumer credit lenders, buy-now-pay-later providers, credit card issuers, and other consumer finance firms are the primary audience. Debt advisers, credit reference agencies, and debt purchasing firms are also in scope.

The FCA's fair value findings draw on reviews of firms across consumer credit lending, debt advice, credit reference agencies and credit information services, and debt purchasing, collection and administration. A separate focused review covered fees and charges at firms offering unsecured loans, credit cards, retail revolving credit, retail finance and high-cost credit. The FCA also reviewed consumer hire and third-party ownership agreements for home energy infrastructure, including boilers, solar panels and air-source heat pumps.

Under the Consumer Duty, a product provides fair value where the amount paid is reasonable relative to the benefits received. The FCA's findings show that many firms are struggling to demonstrate this convincingly.

Where firms are falling short

The most common weaknesses are practical and fixable. Some firms did not account for the full price a customer might pay over the lifetime of a product, omitting contingent charges such as arrears fees. Some assessments included fees no longer charged while leaving out fees customers could still incur. Some relied on narrative assertions with little supporting data. Others did not explain how price compared with benefits.

Non-financial costs, such as customers' time and effort, were often ignored, particularly where firms pointed to the absence of a direct charge as evidence of value.

Few firms considered how value might change over time, for instance after renewal, following a fee change, or when a customer fell into arrears.

On fees specifically, the FCA noted wide variation in what firms considered when determining the reasonable costs associated with late or missed repayments under CONC 7.7.5R, the rule requiring that charges on customers in default or arrears difficulties are no higher than necessary to cover the firm's reasonable costs. Separately, some firms could not demonstrate that their controls were appropriately designed or operating effectively, particularly for customers in financial difficulty.

What good looks like

Strong firms mapped the end-to-end customer journey and assessed value at each stage, including complaints handling and bereavement processes. One credit card provider quantified product benefits such as cashback and foreign exchange savings and compared these directly with fees, interest and other costs. Good practice controls included grace periods, limits on repeat or cumulative charges, and fee waivers or refunds.

Proportionality and next steps

The findings do not create new requirements. Firms should apply judgement and take a proportionate approach for their business, products and customers. Proportionality does not mean a lower standard. Smaller firms do not need complex modelling: they can support their conclusions using existing information such as complaints data, customer feedback, arrears, cancellations, product usage and vulnerability data.

Check your fair value assessments against all three gaps before your next review cycle. If your assessment relies mainly on narrative, omits contingent charges, or has not been revisited to account for how value changes over time, those are the places to start.

Sources