EP26/1: Persistent debt fell from 7% to 3% of credit card accounts, but the FCA cannot prove its rules caused it

The FCA's look back at its 2018 credit card persistent debt rules says they helped, but not that they caused the fall. No new rules or consultation are proposed, so this is Worth reviewing for card lenders.

EP26/1: Persistent debt fell from 7% to 3% of credit card accounts, but the FCA cannot prove its rules caused it
Illustration: AI-generated

Impact: Worth reviewing. The FCA has published Evaluation Paper 26/1 (18 November 2026), a look back at its 2018 credit card persistent debt rules, carried out under its Rule Review Framework (2023). If you lend on credit cards, read it: the lessons centre on customer engagement. If you are not a card lender, there is nothing here for you.

No new rules or consultation are proposed. The FCA asks lenders to check their approach to persistent debt against the paper's lessons, and to contact it with any questions.

What the rules do. Persistent debt means a customer pays more in interest and fees than they repay of what they borrowed, over 18 months or more. The rules, introduced under the 2018 policy statement (PS18/4), require firms to identify those customers and take escalating steps to help them repay faster where affordable. Firms must intervene at 18, 27 and 36 months.

What the FCA found. Between 2018 and early 2023, the share of credit card accounts in persistent debt fell from 7% to 3%. Customers in persistent debt paid less in interest and fees each month, and fewer paid fees. Most customers who received a persistent debt letter left persistent debt within 18 months.

Compliance cost firms £281.6m in total, slightly below the £294.6m to £334.1m range the FCA estimated in PS18/4.

The FCA judges the rules helped. But Covid-19 and the cost-of-living crisis also affected outcomes, so it cannot say the rules caused the changes. It also calls its findings indicative rather than precise, because some firms' data had gaps and inconsistencies that were disproportionate to resolve.

What did not work as well. Not all customers opened their persistent debt communications, and some kept making minimum repayments over long periods. The rules also work less well for customers who cannot afford to pay more, who may need wider support with financial difficulty.

Lessons for lenders. The FCA suggests firms make greater use of what it calls social strategies: ways of encouraging behaviour change that draw on other people. Its examples are social norms messaging (such as 'x% of people make their payments on time'), personal stories about persistent debt, and encouraging customers earlier in the persistent debt journey to call and commit to higher monthly repayments.

Firms also took different approaches, which led to different outcomes. The FCA suggests trade associations could run forums to share what works.

Sources