FCA year 2 operational resilience review: show what you can deliver now, not what you plan to fix
The FCA's review of 2025 to 2026 operational resilience self-assessments says firms should evidence what they can deliver now in disruption, not what they plan to fix. It is guidance, not new rules.
Impact: worth reviewing. The FCA has published Operational resilience: demonstrating resilience in practice, good and poor practice observations from its review of firms' 2025 to 2026 operational resilience self-assessments. They are not new requirements, so there is no deadline to hit. If you are in scope of SYSC 15A, read them before you write your next self-assessment.
Who is affected. The observations are most relevant to firms in scope of SYSC 15A, the FCA's operational resilience rules. Confirm your own position against those rules. Other firms may still find the observations useful for assessing how disruption could affect consumers, clients, market integrity or confidence in the financial system.
The central message. The FCA wants evidence of what you can deliver now, in severe but plausible disruption, not promises about remediation, transformation programmes or future investment. It names the quality of evidence as the main area for development, and says it will expect stronger evidence of current resilience in next self-assessments.
Poor practice, by theme
Evidence of recovery
- Pointing to future improvements or transformation plans without explaining whether you can stay within impact tolerance now.
- Claiming you can recover from every scenario within tolerance, with no evidence.
- Relying on manual workarounds without showing they would work in a severe disruption, including whether they scale over an extended period.
- Reporting few or no vulnerabilities without showing how you reached that conclusion.
Impact tolerances
- Relying too heavily on time-based tolerances, meaning a limit expressed only as a time. Stronger approaches add other measures: customer numbers, transaction volumes and values, harm indicators and outstanding work. Where relevant, they also count customers in vulnerable circumstances or without digital access.
Suppliers and communications
- Relying on assumptions about supplier or group service providers' resilience without testing those assumptions against severe but plausible disruption.
- Offering limited evidence that communications would work if usual channels were unavailable, degraded or compromised.
Governance
- Treating Board approval of the self-assessment as the main evidence of oversight.
- Not showing that UK Boards or senior managers can see dependencies managed at group level.
What good looks like. Stronger firms validate remediation and re-test where needed, rather than treating a closed action as proof that resilience has improved.
What the FCA expects next. Your next self-assessment should show that you understand your residual risk, and how testing, incidents and second and third line input have informed decisions. The requirement to review SYSC 15A compliance at least annually, or after a material change to your business or market, still applies. Where issues persist, the FCA suggests explaining why and setting out the action you will take. That may include:
- improving mapping
- more severe testing
- testing communications
- strengthening Board challenge.