FCA benchmark governance review flags weak board records, key-person risk and poor information flows
The FCA has published findings from a multi-firm governance review of benchmark administrators, identifying weaknesses across five areas. Administrators should read this carefully; wider firms can note it.
Worth reviewing — benchmark administrators. Wider firms: note only. No remediation timeline is given and the review sample size is not disclosed, so the breadth of these weaknesses across the sector is unknown.
The FCA has published findings from a multi-firm governance review of benchmark administrators (Multi-firm Review: Governance in the Benchmarks Sector), completing the final strand of supervisory work prompted by its 2024 portfolio letter. That earlier work had already found weaknesses in governance at a number of administrators, including management information that did not always support effective risk oversight and risk frameworks that were not sufficiently tailored to firms' specific risks.
The review assessed governance across five areas:
- Board composition and capability
- Board engagement, challenge and decisions
- Governance structure, delegation and escalation
- Board packs and information flow
- Governance assurance and continuous improvement
Three findings stand out. First, board records: in some cases minutes did not clearly capture decisions, challenge, rationale and resulting actions. The FCA is not asking for verbatim transcripts, but it does expect concise records that show what was considered, what was decided and who owns the follow-through. Second, agenda design: dense agendas and limited meeting time left boards less able to focus on the issues requiring the most judgement. Third, key-person risk: where the same individual holds several roles across the regulated entity, committees or a wider group, the FCA flagged concerns around capacity, competing priorities and potential conflicts. It also noted the firm's exposure if that individual departs or becomes unavailable.
On information flows, the FCA observed that management information worked best where reporting highlighted changes, exceptions and emerging trends rather than static descriptions of current positions. In some cases, boards received information but there was no clear record of the challenge it prompted or the actions that followed. The FCA also noted that escalation flows between UK regulated entities and wider group governance forums were less developed in some cases, a particular concern given that many administrators sit within larger group structures.
The FCA is explicit that its observations are not a checklist. Each administrator should assess the findings against its own activities, risks, users and operating environment. The FCA's language points toward a considered self-assessment, not a box-ticking exercise.
The FCA will use the findings to inform ongoing supervisory engagement with the sector. It also notes that the Government is currently reviewing the UK Benchmarks Regulation — the framework that governs how administrators are authorised and how benchmarks are produced — and encourages administrators to engage with that reform process. The scope and timeline of that review are not yet confirmed in the source material.
Sources
- Governance benchmarks sectorfca.org.uk