CP26/40: FCA proposes optional charge cap exemption for performance fees in workplace pension defaults
The FCA wants to take certain performance fees outside the 0.75% cap on workplace default funds (CP26/40). If you run contract-based workplace pensions, this is worth reviewing. Responses close 14 January 2027.
Impact: worth reviewing. The FCA has published CP26/40, proposing to exempt certain performance fees (fees linked to how an investment performs) from the charge cap for workplace default pension schemes run by FCA-regulated firms. These are the contract-based schemes. Nothing changes yet, but if you operate contract-based workplace pensions, read it and decide whether to respond. Independent Governance Committees (IGCs), trustees and employers may also want to read it.
What the cap does now. The charge cap was introduced in 2015 and limits charges to 0.75% of funds under management in workplace default pension funds. It exists because employers may have limited ability to influence the charges on their employees' pension savings, and to ensure all savers benefit from lower charges.
What would change. The FCA says the cap in its current form discourages schemes from considering asset classes where performance fees are common, including private equity, venture capital and private credit funds. Under the proposal, certain performance fees would sit outside the cap.
It would also bring FCA rules closer to the position for trust-based schemes (those with trustees and sponsors), where certain performance-linked fees have been excluded from the cap since 2023. The FCA says alignment would support competition and choice and reduce unnecessary complexity for providers operating in both markets.
The exemption would be an option, not an obligation. Providers should use it only where it is in savers' interests and they can meet the relevant protections.
Not a licence to charge more. The FCA is explicit on this. In its press release, Therese Chambers, the FCA's executive director of enforcement and market integrity, said: "greater flexibility is not a licence to charge more. Any higher charges must be justified by additional value, with firms carefully weighing returns, risks and costs when deciding what is in savers' best interests."
The safeguards. The proposed protections cover transparency, fair allocation of fees between savers, and scrutiny of how private assets are valued. Providers and IGCs would need access to the information required to assess whether performance-linked fees offer value for money. Providers would also need strong controls when agreeing performance fees. In a limited number of areas, the FCA goes beyond the trust-based regime, citing market developments since 2023 and supervisory insights.
Dates. Responses close on Thursday 14 January 2027, through the online response form or by email. The FCA expects to make final rules in summer 2027.